Investor profile - OH
Paul Civitello
Paul Civitello is a real estate investor and operator based in Columbus, OH. Public filings show activity across 54 properties held through 14 holding companies. Recent mortgage relationships include Richwood Bank, City National Bank, and COOPER STATE BANK.
Paul's Activity
As of December 2025, public records show approximately $6.5M in recorded mortgage exposure linked to this investor across at least 25 mortgage filings and 54 properties held through 14 holding companies. Activity appears concentrated in residential and multifamily assets recorded between 2010 and 2025.
Primary Geography
Columbus, OH
ZIP codes: 43204, 43223, 43206, 43211, and 43228
Most recorded activity for this investor appears in COLUMBUS, GROVE CITY, DUBLIN, RICHWOOD, and POWELL.
Property Type Breakdown
Associated Entities (14)
OH · 31 properties · 5 mortgages
OH · 6 properties · 5 mortgages
OH · 1 property · 3 mortgages
+11 more not shown
Mortgages (25)
Top Lenders
| Date | Amount | Status | Lender | Borrower | Address |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 01/24/2025 | $86k | Open | FAST FINANCIAL PROS | CB23 HOMES LLC | 1150 MOUNT VERNON AVE, COLUMBUS, OH 43203 |
| 01/24/2025 | $86k | Open | FAST FINANCIAL PROS | CB23 HOMES LLC | - |
| 12/08/2022 | $220k | Open | STEPHEN KLESTINEC | MICHAEL 23 LLC | 724 STOW PL, REYNOLDSBURG, OH 43068 |
+22 more not shown
Owned Properties (54)
| Address | Deeded owner | Status | Consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| 724 STOW PL, REYNOLDSBURG, OH 43068 | MICHAEL 23 LLC | Sold | $465 |
| 591 CLARK AVE, COLUMBUS, OH 43223 | 914 ASSOCIATES LLC | Sold | $0 |
| 1231 SEYMOUR AVE, COLUMBUS, OH 43206 | WINDSOR INVESTMENTS LTD | Sold | $0 |
+51 more not shown
FAQ
What type of real estate does this investor focus on?
Associated mortgages and deeds show activity in residential, multifamily, and office properties across Columbus, OH.
What companies is Paul Civitello associated with?
Paul Civitello is associated with 14 entities based on extracted signatures from public records. Key entities include WINDSOR HOMES LLC, WINDSOR INVESTMENTS LTD, LORMAR INVESTMENTS LLC, 914 ASSOCIATES LLC, and CB23 HOMES LLC.
How many properties are associated with this investor?
At least 54 properties are associated with Paul Civitello and the entities they control, based on signatures extracted from recorded documents connecting Paul Civitello to the entities.
Which lenders has this investor worked with?
Recent mortgage activity references Richwood Bank, City National Bank, and COOPER STATE BANK, indicating a mix of lending relationships.
How recent is their activity?
Records show activity from 2010 through 2025, with the most recent mortgage recorded in 2025.
How is associated activity determined?
Elementix uses AI to extract signatures from recorded documents. These signatures are used to determine the relationships between people and entities. This is a novel approach that goes beyond looking at corporate filings and skip-tracing.
The information displayed on this page is compiled from recorded real estate documents, business filings, and other lawfully available sources. Elementix summarizes and analyzes public record activity related to investment real estate and associated business entities. Any contact indicators shown (such as email domain references or partial phone digits) are provided solely as unverified signals and may be incomplete or outdated.
Elementix is not a consumer reporting agency, and this information does not constitute a consumer report. The data may not be used to make decisions about an individual's eligibility for personal credit, consumer housing, employment, insurance, or any other purpose governed by the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Elementix may suppress certain contact indicators where legally required or where appropriate for safety or privacy reasons. Requests for removal, suppression, or correction of information must be submitted to compliance@elementix.ai. Elementix reviews such requests only where required by applicable law or where information is factually inaccurate. General objections or unsupported demands do not create a removal obligation.