Company Profile
The Mahaffey Company
Multifamily developer, builder, owner-operator. Family-owned enterprise since 1962 specializing in developing, building, owning, and managing large apartment communities in Florida as long-term investments. They emphasize below-market rents, high occupancy (99%), and hands-on involvement from site selection to management. 25 communities with ~20,000 units developed.
Key Statistics
As of June 2026, public records show The Mahaffey Company has $432.8M in total recorded mortgage volume across 16 mortgages, with 26 current property ownerships held through 20 confirmed entities.
Total Mortgage Volume
$378.8M
Current Ownerships
26
Confirmed Entities
20
Associated People
20
Entities (20)
The Mahaffey Company operates through 20 confirmed holding companies and entities identified from public records.
FL · 0 properties · 3 mortgages
FL · 1 property · 2 mortgages
FL · 0 properties · 1 mortgage
FL · 1 property · 1 mortgage
FL · 17 properties · 1 mortgage
+15 more entities not shown
People (20)
Key individuals associated with The Mahaffey Company based on signatures extracted from recorded documents and public filings.
Former President · 13 mortgages · 3 properties
Appears on 2 affiliated entities: CARLTON ARMS OF WINTER PARK LLLP (FL), CARLTON ARMS OF ST PETERSBURG LLLP (FL).
Partner · 13 mortgages · 20 properties
Appears on 7 affiliated entities: MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES LAKE DEXTER LLC (FL), CARLTON AT BARTRAM PARK LLC (FL), MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES JACKSONVILLE LLC (FL), MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES FORT MYERS LLC (FL), MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES WEST MELBOURNE LLC (FL) and 2 more.
Former Director (retired from daily duties January 2020) · 12 mortgages · 5 properties
Appears on 2 affiliated entities: CARLTON AT BARTRAM PARK LLC (FL), MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES WEST MELBOURNE LLC (FL).
Chairman of the Board · 12 mortgages · 2 properties
Appears on 5 affiliated entities: CARLTON ARMS OF WINTER HAVEN LLC (FL), CARLTON ARMS OF NORTH LAKELAND LLC (FL), CARLTON ARMS OF WINTER PARK LLLP (FL), CARLTON ARMS OF ST PETERSBURG LLLP (FL), MAHAFFEY ALOMA LLC (FL).
+16 more people not shown
Properties (26)
| Address | Entity | Status | Consideration |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2526 MCJUNKIN RD, LAKELAND, FL 33803 | MKIS HOLDINGS LLC | Owns | $725k |
| 2205 CLEVELAND HEIGHTS BLVD, LAKELAND, FL 33803 | HOLLINGSWORTH HEIGHTS LLC | Owns | $810k |
| 7350 MOCCASIN WALLOW RD, PALMETTO, FL 34221 | MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES ROBINSON GATEWAY LLC | Owns | $11.6M |
+29 more not shown
Top Lenders
The following lenders have the most recorded mortgage volume with The Mahaffey Company entities.
Geography
The Mahaffey Company has recorded real estate activity in the following states.
FAQ
What does The Mahaffey Company do?
Multifamily developer, builder, owner-operator. Family-owned enterprise since 1962 specializing in developing, building, owning, and managing large apartment communities in Florida as long-term investments. They emphasize below-market rents, high occupancy (99%), and hands-on involvement from site selection to management. 25 communities with ~20,000 units developed.
How many entities are associated with The Mahaffey Company?
The Mahaffey Company operates through 20 confirmed entities identified from signatures on recorded documents. Key entities include CARLTON AT BARTRAM PARK LLC, MAHAFFEY ASSOCIATES JACKSONVILLE LLC, and CARLTON ARMS OF WINTER HAVEN LLC.
Who are the key people at The Mahaffey Company?
Public records and filings associate 20 individuals with The Mahaffey Company. Key people include James Mahaffey (Former President), Thomas Mahaffey (Partner), and Suzanne Gray (Former Director (retired from daily duties January 2020)).
How many properties does The Mahaffey Company own?
Public records show 26 current property ownerships associated with The Mahaffey Company entities, with $378.8M in total recorded mortgage volume.
Which lenders has The Mahaffey Company worked with?
Top lending relationships include US Bank, Truist Bank, and Berkadia, based on recorded mortgage data.
How is this data collected?
Elementix aggregates data from recorded real estate documents, business filings, and other lawfully available sources. We use AI to extract signatures, identify entity relationships, and connect people to the companies they operate through.
The information displayed on this page is compiled from recorded real estate documents, business filings, and other lawfully available sources. Elementix summarizes and analyzes public record activity related to investment real estate and associated business entities.
Elementix is not a consumer reporting agency, and this information does not constitute a consumer report. The data may not be used to make decisions about an individual's eligibility for personal credit, consumer housing, employment, insurance, or any other purpose governed by the Fair Credit Reporting Act.
Requests for removal, suppression, or correction of information must be submitted to [email protected]. Elementix reviews such requests only where required by applicable law.